Entradas

Mostrando las entradas etiquetadas como Critical Thinking

Making a Reasoned Judgement: Influence of Violent Movies

Imagen
Media nowadays has a great effect on kids. It influences their way of seeing the world and interacting with it. Many movies, videogames and TV shows have been accused of influencing kids with extremely graphic visuals of violence, therefore suggesting the idea that murder, physical harassment and deadly attacks are an unavoidable issue on our society. However in order to relate them with this claims, there must be some kind of evidence review. In our thinking skills class we analyzed the case of two boys who had killed a fellow partner. Different sources argued about the role of the movie Childs Play 3. After carefully going through corroborative, meaning in favor, and conflicted evidence, meaning against; as well as the weight and quality of each of the two sides, taking into account the credibility of each one of them; we arrived to the following conclusion: Analyzing all evidence, strong and neutral sources have expressed their opinion and conduct research in this topic. We, fin...

MadMen: The Smoking Pitch

Imagen
Around the world there are millions of different sources that provide us information from every kind. However some information may rely in more accurate concepts and fundaments. There´s where the concept of credibility appears. Each source, from people, to magazines, to newspapers, can be more or less credible. That´s why we use a credibility criteria in order to identify the concept. One of the ideas we take into account in the credibility criteria is the vested interest. Companies, governments, etc sometimes have a personal interest in the outcame of a decision or situation. That is why they may distort information in other to favour themselves. Consequently, reducing the credibility. In class we saw an extract of the tv serie MadMen: We analysed it and answered the following questions: 1. Identify some of the vested interest in this scene. How do these work? 2. Why is Peter´s idea rejected and Dom´s idea accepted? 3. Find and old tobacco advertising picture and analyse it i...

Unit 1: Truth and Credibility

Imagen
At school, we have a subject called thinking skills, where we study Critical thinking. The skills required to analyse and evaluate arguments are taught in this subject. The term argument consists of a reason or reasons which support a conclusion. To support a certain point of view or a particular belief, we need evidence, if not the argument is not reliable. Moreover, we ought to make a judgement about the credibility of the evidence in each argument. In order to do this judgement, we need to focus on the source, which is where the evidence comes from. The source might be an eyewitness, a TV Programme or an article in a magazine and etc. Furthermore, we must use a credibility criteria. This criteria can be divided as it follows: Neutrality : It consists of a source which is impartial and which does not have a motive to distort evidence for its own benefit.  Vested Interest : When a source takes a side and manipulates or selects certain parts of the evidence for its own benefit...